Yes, until you get an example case study for a new niche. When I ran cold email campaigns, our first question was always what niche you're in. Then we built a list of businesses just like the ones in the portfolio and pitched all of them against that one example.
Should you stick to niches you've worked in for cold outreach?
A service provider at Friday Strategy Sips was getting ready for cold outreach and asked if that meant sticking to the niches she'd already worked in, and that now wasn't the time to diversify.
Not until you get an example case study for a new one.
Just for context, I used to work for the largest cold email company in probably the United States, and I ran a ton of campaigns for them on the back end.
How to build a cold email list from your portfolio
People would come in, and our first strategy literally was: what niche are you in?
Then we'd find businesses comparable to the ones they'd already worked with, the ones in their case study portfolios.
For example, if a web design company came in, we'd go into their portfolio and see which websites they'd done. If they did one for a catering business, and it was a beautiful example, we'd build the list from catering businesses in the United States. Then we'd pitch all of them against that one portfolio piece.
What to do when your portfolio has more than one niche
And they had different niches in their portfolios. Yes, you can have multiple niches in one business.
So if you've done social strategy for other people and you got results, go through the types of businesses you did social strategy for. That's how you pitch it cold.
What to send each business on your niche list
Because the list matches your work, your first cold email is simple: I did this for your competitor, these are the results, are you interested in chatting?
And the case study doesn't have to live on a website. You can do a portfolio as a PDF. That's still extremely professional, and one or two case studies can be all you need.
How to cold pitch a niche you haven't worked in yet
Wait until you have a case study there. If you're starting in an area that's new for you, send a quick audit instead: look at their business, come up with some specific things they could change, and pitch them that.
It's a little more work because you do it one-on-one. So once you get something in your portfolio for that niche, change it.
Conclusion
Your portfolio already tells you who to cold pitch. Start with the niches you have proof for, and add a new one once you have a case study there.
Have a question you need answered? Every Friday at 6:30 PM Eastern, I do free live business consulting at Friday Strategy Sips. Just show up and ask.