Free live business consulting every Friday at 6:30 pm ET. RSVP →
Contact

How Do You Warm Up an Old Email List?

How Do You Warm Up an Old Email List?

Sell to it. When a list has been sitting too long, I drop it straight into a sales funnel and let the people who aren't going to buy unsubscribe. Whoever survives the sales funnel is your people, and that's who you start sending newsletters to.

How do you warm up an old email list?

A service provider at Friday Strategy Sips told me she has an email list she hasn't used, and she knows she needs to warm it up.

I drop them into sales. That's how I like to warm up a list that's been sitting too long.

It's a more aggressive way. But when I have clients and we're trying to move really quickly, we warm up by selling.

From Friday Strategy Sips: Warm up a cold email list by SELLING

What happens when you drop an old list into a sales funnel

Drop them into a sales funnel, and let the people who aren't going to buy unsubscribe.

If they survive the sales funnel, that's your people. Then start marketing to them: send the newsletters and pitch your services.

Why unsubscribes from an old list are a good sign

If they unsubscribe, it's a celebration, because people get nervous about that. That person was not your person. They were not going to buy.

I do the same thing with new subscribers. They have to get sold to first, and either unsubscribe or just get out of the way. You can't skip my selling to read a newsletter.

The more I get people to unsubscribe, the more my list gets really good, and that's when it starts converting very well for me.

Two gentler ways to email a list you've never emailed

There are two ways.

  1. The free gift. If you create a new free gift, or they haven't had access to your free gift, offer it: hey, I know it's been a while, but I've been working on something and I wanted to share it with you. It's completely free.
  2. A life update. People love those. Email them and say: hey, I've been quiet for a while, but here's what's been happening. Then list it out in detail.

Put the subject line really simple, all lowercase, like "hey, what's up", so people just open it. People reply back and encourage you, or hopefully they unsubscribe if they don't want emails anymore.

But you get one chance to do this. You can't ghost again afterwards, so get the rest of your funnel together too.

Conclusion

An old list isn't dead. Sell to it, let the wrong people leave, and start sending newsletters to whoever stays.

Have a question you need answered? Every Friday at 6:30 PM Eastern, I do free live business consulting at Friday Strategy Sips. Just show up and ask.

FAQ

FAQs About Warming Up an Old Email List

How do you warm up an old email list?

Drop it into a sales funnel. Let the people who aren't going to buy unsubscribe, then start sending newsletters to the people who stay.

Is it bad if people unsubscribe from an old list?

No. It's a celebration. That person was not your person, and the more people unsubscribe, the better your list converts.

When do you start sending newsletters to an old list?

After they get through the sales funnel. If they survive it, that's your people.

Is there a gentler way to email a list you haven't used?

Yes. Offer a new free gift, or send a life update about what's been happening.

What subject line should you use for an old list?

Something really simple, all lowercase, like "hey, what's up".

What do you do after you email an old list?

Don't ghost again. Get the rest of your funnel together first.

Tierra Wilson, AI & Business Growth Consultant for service-based businesses

About the author

Tierra Wilson

Tierra Wilson is an AI & Business Growth Consultant for service-based businesses with 15 years in tech, 500+ clients, and consulting credits with Google, MyFitnessPal, Under Armour, Hewlett-Packard, USPS, and GoDaddy. She's a founding member of the Google Small Business Advisory Board and a former GoDaddy Pro Council member. She also runs AiBT Advisory, an AI deployment firm for mid-market companies.

Everything on this blog comes from real experience running real service-based businesses.

More about Tee

I'm here

want to talk through this?

If you read this and have questions about how it applies to your business, I'm happy to chat. Book 30 minutes and tell me what you're working on.

Book 30 minutes