Free live business consulting every Friday at 6:30 pm ET. RSVP →
Contact

How Deep Should Your Content Go on Substack vs. TikTok?

How Deep Should Your Content Go on Substack vs. TikTok?

Go deep on Substack, and keep TikTok quick. Someone scrolling TikTok or scanning their inbox is moving fast, but someone sitting down to read a Substack or a blog post has room for depth. Never dumb your expertise down. Just run it through a sixth grader test to pull out the jargon.

Is it okay to go deep on Substack?

Someone who teaches a technical subject came to Friday Strategy Sips. Her TikToks are quick and relatable, but on Substack she wanted to give the full picture. Not just a short blurb about what she's trying to educate people on. She wanted to go deeper.

Yes. It's okay to go deeper, especially on Substack.

Intellectual thought leaders are a huge deal over there. There are some on Instagram and YouTube too. So you never want to dumb it down, especially at that level of expertise.

From Friday Strategy Sips: Go DEEP on Substack, keep TikTok quick

There's a whole intellectual movement happening on Substack and long-form YouTube right now. Deep thought, long reads. Don't be afraid to go deep on Substack. That's really what it's made for.

Substack vs. TikTok: where should you spend your time?

Start with how each one gets your content in front of people.

TikTokSubstack
How people find youAlgorithm-based and search-based: it serves your video up to people, and people search for it tooSearch-based: people search for what you wrote
How long a post livesUp to a monthForever
How deep to goKeep it quick and relatableGo deep. It's made for long reads
Who's thereEveryone scrollingThought leaders and intellectual readers
What you postShort videos and carouselsArticles, plus Notes to the feed
Best forGetting in front of new people fastBeing known for your thinking

TikTok is algorithm-based and search-based now. It serves your video up to people, and people search for it too, so a TikTok can keep getting found for up to a month. Substack is search-based, like Pinterest, long-form YouTube and blogging. Someone is searching for what you wrote, so those posts live forever.

Substack is also where the thought leaders are. It has Notes, so you can post to the feed as well as publish your articles. If you want to be known for your thinking, that's where I'd go, along with LinkedIn.

But nobody can tell you which one will work for you until you test it. I do all the marketing for my clients, and for the first 30 days we throw everything at every algorithm. By month two, we know which one it is, and it's never the same. For one person it's TikTok. For another it's a Facebook page. For me, shockingly, it was TikTok. I did not think it was.

So don't pick one and hope. Post on both for 30 days, and let the data talk back to you.

Why your TikTok content should stay quick

A TikTok video is quick. Sometimes an inbox is the same way: you're just scanning through your emails.

But if someone's sitting down and reading a blog post or a Substack, it is totally okay for you to get a lot deeper there.

And Substack is a blog. They rebranded it. You post articles on it, and the algorithm works just like any other social media network, pushing it out to other people. So treat it like a place people come to read.

How to go deep without losing people in jargon

Going deep doesn't mean using all your jargon.

Something I do sometimes, especially when I'm talking about AI, which can be complex at the level I do it: I run it through the sixth grader test in AI. I take what I wrote and ask, can a sixth grader understand this? It helps me pick out the jargon.

We're such experts in our fields, and that's a blessing and a curse. Sometimes we try to talk about stuff that we really should wait to share until they hire us. When I'm doing my TikTok videos, I'm talking down to earth to people. If you hired me for strategy, my language would sound completely different.

Conclusion

Match the depth to where people are reading. Quick on TikTok, deep on Substack, and plain language everywhere.

Have a question you need answered? Every Friday at 6:30 PM Eastern, I do free live business consulting at Friday Strategy Sips. Just show up and ask.

FAQ

FAQs About Content Depth on Substack and TikTok

Should I be on Substack or TikTok?

Nobody can tell you until you test it. Post on both for 30 days, and let the data talk back to you.

Is it okay to write long, in-depth posts on Substack?

Yes. Intellectual thought leaders are a huge deal on Substack. That's really what it's made for.

Should I dumb down my expertise for social media?

Never dumb it down. Keep it quick on TikTok, and strip out the jargon.

How do I make technical content easier to understand?

Run it through the sixth grader test in AI: ask whether a sixth grader could understand it, and it'll help you pick out the jargon.

What is Substack?

It's a blog that's been rebranded. You post articles, and its algorithm pushes them out to other people like any other social network.

Why should TikTok content be quick?

A TikTok video is quick, and people move fast there. Save the depth for where people sit down to read.

Tierra Wilson, AI & Business Growth Consultant for service-based businesses

About the author

Tierra Wilson

Tierra Wilson is an AI & Business Growth Consultant for service-based businesses with 15 years in tech, 500+ clients, and consulting credits with Google, MyFitnessPal, Under Armour, Hewlett-Packard, USPS, and GoDaddy. She's a founding member of the Google Small Business Advisory Board and a former GoDaddy Pro Council member. She also runs AiBT Advisory, an AI deployment firm for mid-market companies.

Everything on this blog comes from real experience running real service-based businesses.

More about Tee

I'm here

want to talk through this?

If you read this and have questions about how it applies to your business, I'm happy to chat. Book 30 minutes and tell me what you're working on.

Book 30 minutes